Posted in Algebra

Math knowledge for teaching fractions and decimals

No one can teach mathematics without knowing mathematics but not everyone who knows mathematics can teach it well. Below are two tasks about teaching fractions and decimals that would give us a sense of the kind of mathematical knowledge we teachers need to know apart from knowledge of the content of mathematics. As teachers it is expected of us to have knowledge of students difficulties and misconceptions in specific domains of mathematics. We are also expected to know the different representations or models of concepts to design an effective instruction. The two tasks were used in a study about mathematical knowledge for teaching of pre-service teachers.

Task 1

You are teaching in 7th grade. You want to work on multiplication of fractions, using the following numbers:

a) 10 x 3        b) 10 x 3/4          c. 10 x 1 1/5         d. 10/11 x 1 1/5

  • Create a problem using an everyday context, accessible to students and easily visualized, that uses the repeated addition sense for multiplication;
  • Prepare an illustration that works and that you could use for all numbers to help students visualize the operation;
  • Show, for each case, with the illustration and specific explanations, how one can make sense of c) from the answer obtained in a).
Task 2
Arrange the following numbers from the least to the greatest:
           2.46        2.254        2.3       2.052          2.32
Many of your students have written:
2.052     2.3         2.32        2.46     2.254
An others have written:                    
2.052     2.254     2.32        2.46        2.3
Complete the following steps:
  1. Describe and make sense of the error(s) committed by students;
  2. Find a similar task in which the students’ reasoning would lead to the same error, confirming their strategy;
  3. Find a similar task in which the students’ reasoning would lead to a right answer;
  4. How would you intervene in these difficulties
This is the third in the series of posts on mathematical knowledge for teaching. The first is about Tangents to Curves and the second one is about Counting Cubes.
You may use the comment section below to answer the questions or share your thoughts about mathematics teaching.  I hope you find time to discuss this with your co-teachers.
Posted in Algebra

Math knowledge for teaching tangent to a curve

I am creating a new category of posts about mathematical tasks aimed at developing teachers’ math knowledge for teaching. Most of the tasks I will present here have been used in studies about teaching and teacher learning. Mathematical knowledge for teaching was coined by J. Boaler based on what Shulman (1986) call pedagogical content knowledge (PCK) or subject-matter knowledge for teaching. I know this is a blog and not a discussion forum but with the comment section at the bottom of the post, there’s nothing that should prevent the readers from answering the questions and giving their thoughts about the task. Your thoughts and sharing will help enrich knowledge for teaching the math concepts involve in the task.

The following task was originally given to teachers to explore teachers beliefs to sufficiency of a visual argument.

The task:

Year 12 students, specializing in mathematics, were given the following question:
Examine whether the line y = 2 is tangent to the graph of the function f, where f(x) = x^3 + 2.

Two students responded as follows:

Student A: I will find the common point between the line and the graph and solving the system

math

The common point is A(0,2). The line is tangent of the graph at point A because they have only one common point (which is A).’

Student B: The line is not tangent to the graph because, even though they have one common

tangentpoint, the line cuts across the graph, as we can see in the figure.

Questions:

a. In your view what is the aim of the above exercise? (Why would a teacher give the problem to students?)

b. How do you interpret the choices made by each of the students in their responses above?

c. What feedback would you give to each of the students above with regard to their response to the exercise?

Source: Teacher Beliefs and the Didactic Contract on Visualisation by Irene Biza, Elena Nardi, Theodossios Zachariades.

Posted in Algebra, Math blogs

Math Teachers at Play Blog Carnival

Math  Teachers At Play- Blog Carnival #49 of Let’s Play Math is now live in TeachBesideMe. Go check-out the fabulous submissions and of course the photos and images.

Mathematics for Teaching will be hosting the 50th edition of MTaP. You may use the  Math Teachers at Play Blog Carnival — Submission Form to submit your posts or email it to mathforteaching@gmail.com. MTAP 50 will go live on 2nd week of May.  Looking forward to your great articles on teaching and learning mathematics . Thank you.
Posted in Algebra, GeoGebra worksheets, Math Lessons

Teaching maximum area problem with GeoGebra

Remember that classic maximum area problem? Here’s a version of it: Pam wishes to fence off a rectangular vegetable garden in her backyard. She has 18 meters of  fencing wire which she will use to fence three sides of the garden with the existing fence forming the fourth side. Calculate the maximum area she can enclose.

This problem is usually given as an application problem and is solved algebraically. For example if x is one of the two equal sides to be fenced then the area is the function f(x) = x (18-2x). The maximum area can be found by graphing or by inspection. If students have done a bit of calculus already then they can use the first derivate to solve the problem. But with free technology such as GeoGebra, there should be no excuse not to make the teaching of this topic less abstract especially for Year 9 or 10 students. It need not be at the end of the chapter on quadratic but as an introductory lesson for quadratics. Here’s a GeoGebra applet I made which can be used to teach this topic more visually and conceptually. Below is the image of the applet. I did not embed the applet here because it takes a while to load. Click maximum_area_problem worksheet to explore.

Here’s my suggested teaching approach using this applet. Students need to be given a bit of time exploring it before asking them the following questions:

  1. Pam wishes to fence off a rectangular vegetable garden in her backyard. She found fencing wires stored in their garage which she will use to fence three sides of the garden with the existing fence forming the fourth side. How long is Pam’s fencing wire? What are some of the sizes of gardens Pam can have with the fencing wires?
  2. If you were Pam, what garden size will you choose? Why?
  3. What do the coordinates of P represent? How about the path of P, what information can we get from it?
  4. As the length of BD changes so does the length of the other two sides. What equation will describe the relationship between the length of BD and EF? between BD and DE? between BD and area BDEF.
  5. What equation of function will run through the path of P? Type it in the input bar to check.
  6. What does the tip of the graph tell you about the area of the garden?

Feel free to use the comments sections for other questions and suggestions for teaching this topic. How to teach the derivative function without really trying is a good sequel to this lesson. More lessons in Math Lessons in Mathematics for Teaching.